Showing posts with label Fantasy and Science Fiction Books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fantasy and Science Fiction Books. Show all posts

Sunday, March 31, 2013

She Reads Book Club Book Review: The Silence of Bonaventure Arrow by Rita Leganski

The March pick for the She Reads Book Club is a southern tale steeped in a mixture of voodoo magic, Catholicism, and full-flavored roux. Wonderful and strange, Rita Leganski's debut novel The Silence of Bonaventure Arrow is sure to delight, sadden, and touch the soul every reader.

Set in the mid-twentieth century in a fictional town in Lousiana, Leganski's novel tells the story of Bonaventure Arrow. An exceptional young man with an auditory gift, Bonaventure is born into a world of sorrow. When tragedy strikes his family weeks before his birth, Bonaventure takes on the weight of the mourning, guilt, and longing his family members feel. Bonaventure is different from other children; he cannot speak, but he hears the sounds that come from blades of grass, rocks, and bird feathers.

To say too much more about the plot would ruin the book. Leganski breaks all kinds of "rules" for writing fiction, but prevails nonetheless. The Silence of Bonaventure Arrow was a novel I wanted to devour in one sitting, yet spread out over several days so that it would last. From her chapter titles to her writing style, Leganski wrote a novel that is perfect in every way.

Breaking the "show, don't tell" rule was a leap of faith, but one that paid off in the end. While much of the novel is "told" to the reader rather than "shown" in descriptive writing, Leganski creates the perfect voice for this brave novel -- a third-person narrator that the reader depends upon. Through this objective, omniscient eye, the characters come to life in all their wonderfully-flawed glory. Some remain lovable still, and some the object of further scorn, but this daring narrative distance allows their true colors to shine.

The Silence of Bonaventure Arrow broke my heart into a million pieces more than once, yet it also somehow filled my soul with hope in the end. Bonaventure's innocence and the goodness that shines through him will cause in readers a renewed sense of faith in humankind. The novel is about many things, but at its core it is the story of one brave young man and the people who love him.

Leganski has written a novel that is far from anything else -- it is a magical tale that begs to be told. For more thoughts on this beautiful book, visit the She Reads Book Club March Selection page, where bloggers from all over the web have linked their reviews. To join in the book club discussion, click here. If you'd like to read the first chapter, HarperCollins has a preview of the book here.

The She Reads pick for April is Patti Callahan Henry's new novel And Then I Found You. I am super-excited about this one, as I LOVED Henry's last novel Coming Up For Air. Look for my thoughts on the new book in the next few weeks!

Tuesday, July 10, 2012

Book Review: Shadow of Night by Deborah Harkness

Yesterday, I reviewed Deborah Harkness's first novel A Discovery of Witches. Today, I'm telling you about Shadow of Night, the second book in Harkness's All Souls Trilogy. If you haven't read either title, I suggest you click over to my review from yesterday before continuing to read below. My review of Shadow of Night contains some unavoidable spoilers for the first book. If you don't mind, read on! I just like to give fair warning, as I detest spoilers myself.


A bit about the book: Time travel is a perk of the fantasy genre, and in her latest book Shadow of Night, Deborah Harkness makes excellent use of this convention. At the end of A Discovery of Witches, main characters Diana Bishop and Matthew Clairmont found themselves under attack by creatures of all sorts. After Diana requested a manuscript linked to the history of witches, vampires, and daemons in the Oxford library, she became an instant target.

In Shadow of Night, Diana and Matthew time travel back to the year 1590 in order to escape their current-world problems. Additionally, they hope to find some clues about Ashmole 782, the much-sought-after manuscript that began it all. As they travel to various locations in Europe, Harkness weaves a tale of love, mystery, and history all bound into one.


Why you want to read it: One reason I hailed A Discovery of Witches as a must-read rather than just another story full of vampires is because of Harkness's highly intelligent storytelling. She is not simply one more author throwing her hat into a genre because it seems like an easy sell. Instead, Harkness is gifting the world with a complex, well-written trilogy of books. Shadow of Night is a fantasy tale on par with The Lord of the Rings, not one of the many poorly-penned vampire series that popped up in the wake of Stephenie Meyer's success. If it seems like I'm repeating myself, I probably am -- but I just don't want these books lumped in with all the others.

Shadow of Night is rich with the European history in which Harkness is an expert. Even the title refers to Matthew's circle of friends, the real-life group called the School of Night. Members (both from history and from Harkness's novel) include explorer Sir Walter Raleigh, playwright Christopher Marlowe, poet George Chapman, and scientist Thomas Harriot, among others. Harkness brings these staid characters to life in the pages of Shadow of Night, no small feat in my opinion. Although historical fiction is never my first choice, in Harkness's hands it becomes fascinating. Harkness also populates her novel with other historical figures, including Queen Elizabeth and Shakespeare himself.


The bottom line: History weaving and brilliant writing aside, in Shadow of Night Harkness has spun a tale that would capture the attention of almost any reader. The love between Diana and Matthew becomes much more complicated and deeper on every level. The plot is involved and intertwined delightfully with historical figures and events, including the growing fear surrounding witchcraft that results in trials and persecutions all over the world. And finally, there is the growing mystery surrounding Ashmole 782, which continues with a vengeance in this second book in the series. Harkness hasn't yet set a date for the third novel to be released, but suffice it to say I'll be reading it!


About the author: Deborah Harkness is the author of one previous novel, A Discovery of Witches, and two non-fiction titles. She has been a scholar of history for more than twenty years, working in various college and library settings. She is currently a professor at USC, specializing in European history and the history of science. You can find more information about her books by visiting her website, adding her on Facebook, or following her on Twitter.

Monday, July 9, 2012

Book Review: A Discovery of Witches by Deborah Harkness

A bit about the book: In a world filled with witches, vampires, and daemons, love seems out of reach. However, for one witch it just may come from the most unexpected place.

Diana Bishop (yes, descended from the Bishop you've heard of in connection with the Salem witch trials) is an academic, first and foremost. Although she is technically a witch, she has long denied her heritage, opting to live primarily in the real world rather than the magical one. However, on a work-related sojourn to Oxford as part of her Yale professorship, she is pulled quite unassumingly into the world of other beings. Upon requesting a manuscript from Oxford's library as part of her alchemy research, Diana unleashes a storm of magic too strong for her to ignore.

As creatures of all sorts descend on the library, drawn to the power they feel both from Diana and the manuscript, one particular vampire holds them at bay. Matthew Clairmont, a 1500-year-old vampire, is the only being powerful enough to protect Diana -- and to attempt to get his own hands on the manuscript in question. The mysteries surrounding Ashmole 782, the impenetrable manuscript, create a ripple in the supernatural community that threatens their world.

What are the secrets it holds? And what lengths will other creatures, including Matthew, go to to get what they want from Diana?


Why you want to read it: Although it seems the literary world (crossing over into movies, and television, of course) is already quite full enough of fantasy novels -- especially those featuring vampires -- Deborah Harkness's A Discovery of Witches is the one book everyone still needs to read. For one thing, Harkness's tale is no adolescent romance. Neither does it portray vampires as sex objects to be craved.

Instead, A Discovery of Witches is the thinking man and woman's answer to a new kind of fantasy writing. Harkness, a scholar much like her main character (although, we might presume, without the witch's capabilities), blends intelligent historical fact with fiction in the novel. She not only spins an amazingly good story, but she does so with a good vocabulary and little indulgence in typical vampire fiction feeding scenes. A Discovery of Witches is a well-crafted novel and couldn't be further from the Twilight series and other teen-vampire books.

I listened to the audio version of this book, via Audible.com, and the performance by Jennifer Ikeda was phenomenal. The novel weighed in at a lengthy 24 hours (the print version is almost 600 pages long), but did not bore or disappoint. Although it took me quite a while to listen, hearing the story with Ikeda's narration was worth every second.


The bottom line: At last the world has been given an intelligent vampire novel. With the exception of perhaps Anne Rice's novels (which I haven't read), literature has recently been flooded with sub-par vampire writing, making the entire genre into a bit of a joke. Harkness's A Discovery of Witches, the first in a trilogy, turns that around. The novel makes it possible to enjoy good literature and a vampire-filled tale, all at the same time. Although ostensibly a novel about supernatural creatures and their history, Harkness expertly weaves in a love story, as well.


About the author: Deborah Harkness is a current professor of European history and the history of science at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. Having previously written two non-fiction titles, A Discovery of Witches is her first novel. It is also the first in the All Souls Trilogy series. You can find more information and connect with the author on YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter.

Harkness's second novel will release in stores tomorrow. Check back then for my review of Shadow of Night.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

The Other Life Offers a Look (Or Possibly More) at the Path Not Taken

Quinn Braverman is a woman in mourning. On the surface, everything seems fine. She is happily married to a devoted husband; she has a young son who adores her; and she has a new baby on the way. But Quinn is an emotional disaster underneath her thin veneer of contentment. After she and husband Lewis receive difficult news about their unborn daughter, years of grief and regret catch up with Quinn, and she quickly reaches her breaking point.

In her novel The Other Life, Ellen Meister examines the two pivotal events that haunt Quinn: her mother's suicide, first and foremost; and her break-up with Eugene, a troubled radio personality whom Quinn was in a relationship with just prior to her marriage. The mother-daughter relationship between Quinn and Nan, her mother, is in many ways typical. However, Meister throws mental illness into the mix, as well. Nan has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, a disease that eventually causes her demise. Meister expertly illustrates the often-difficult, but always-loving interactions between the two women. She does so in a wide array of scenes, from flashbacks, to private moments of Nan painting, to moments which are pure fantasy.

The fantasy aspect rarely works for me as a reader, but in Meister's hands, even the most unbelievable impossibility seems an easy reality. Quinn has long been aware of a parallel life that exists, one in which she stayed single and (somewhat) happy with Eugene. In that world, her son Isaac and her unborn daughter do not exist; her marriage to Lewis was never a thought. Now, for the first time, Quinn begins to consider crossing over from her "real" life to the parallel one accessible through various portals she can simply feel.

Can she leave Lewis, Isaac, and the baby, while simultaneously leaving behind all the heartache of this life? Is the life she's living on the other side that much better than what she has?

Meister has written a novel that speaks of the human spirit, with all its desires, selfishness, longing, and greed -- and yet, Meister also writes of enormous love and sacrifice. In her hands, Quinn is not a monster who dreams of leaving her family, but rather a broken woman seeking solace from all that ails her. As a reader, I struggled with Quinn's decisions as much as she did. Rather than seeming purely selfish, Quinn is a vibrant character who will fill readers with genuine empathy.

Ellen Meister is the author of two other novels, Secret Confessions of the Applewood PTA and The Smart One. HBO has optioned The Other Life as an upcoming television series. Meister's publisher, Berkley Trade (a division of Penguin), is offering a giveaway copy to readers of A Worn Path. Scroll down or click here to enter to win your own copy of the novel. For more about Meister, visit her website or her blog Side Dish.

Monday, December 5, 2011

Monday Giveaway: Ellen Meister's The Other Life (Optioned by HBO as Upcoming Series)

I, like many other Americans, love me some Sunday night HBO. This is the night that begat Sex and the City, The Sopranos, The Wire, Deadwood, and many more favorites. When a book has been optioned by HBO, you know that a) it must be pretty good and b) it must get all kinds of crazy at some point. In this case, yes, it is; and yes, it does.

Ellen Meister's The Other Life is a little bit like The Time Traveler's Wife, but without most of the lovey-dovey moments. In fact, Meister's form of time-and-space travel is not so much time travel as it is parallel universe travel. That's right -- I said "parallel universe."

Before you instantaneously tune out and click over to another website, hear me out. You'll hear the whole story tomorrow, when I post my review, but suffice it to say: this gal (not a sci-fi/ fantasy fan) loved this book. Like, read-it-on-the-elliptical-at-the-gym loved it. And that is not easy. It may look easy, but sweating it out while balancing a book on a half-inch shelf is not simple. It takes enormous balancing and holding skills. It takes want-to (as in, you really have to want to read that book in order to do it).

Berkley Trade, a division of Penguin, is offering readers of the blog a chance to win a copy of Meister's The Other Life. In the novel, protagonist Quinn Braverman faces multiple life-altering choices. A quick look at the book from the author's website:
Quinn Braverman is keeping two secrets from her loving husband, Lewis. One is that the real reason she chose him over Eugene, her neurotic, semi-famous ex-boyfriend, was to prove to her mother that she could have a happy, stable relationship with the guy next door.
The other is that Quinn knows another life exists in which she made the other choice and stayed with Eugene. The two lives run in parallel lines, like highways on opposite sides of a mountain. There, on the other side, the Quinn who stayed with Eugene is speeding through her high-drama, childless life in Manhattan. Here, the Quinn who married Lewis lives in the suburbs, drives a Volvo, and has an adorable young son with another baby on the way.
But the important part of the secret—the part that terrifies and thrills her—is that she knows it's possible to cross from one life to the other.
That does have the ring of an HBO series, doesn't it?
 
In order to enter the contest to win a copy of The Other Life, fill out the form below. In addition to the usual name, email, and address questions, I'm also asking you to weigh in on the book's theme. Obviously, parallel universes aren't reality. But what if they were? What would you choose? The life you're living, or one you regret giving up? Tell me about your life choice, and I may share it on the blog when I announce the winner.

 

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

The Leftovers Novel Leaves Something Lacking, But HBO Series in Progress

I have to go outside the norm for this review, and say that I was somewhat disappointed with Tom Perrotta's The Leftovers. Perrotta's novels have invariably entertained me; when I finally read Little Children a few years ago, I immediately went back and read the rest of his novels. I enjoyed them all. I thought his characters were cunning and clever, his plots outrageous and realistic all at once. When I found out he was coming to the Southern Festival of Books in October, I promptly wrote up an ode to Perrotta during my countdown posts.

I also need to be honest and say that the premise for The Leftovers did not appeal to me from the get-go. I haven't read Christian-based accounts of the supposed apocalypse, such as Left Behind; I don't watch or read science fiction-based versions of a post-apocalyptic world (i.e., Cormac McCarthy's The Road, in either book or movie versions). Part of this distancing myself from human tellings of a second coming is a certain revulsion with people speaking about and telling tales they can't possibly know the truth about. Similar to Harold Camping and his wild predictions of the world ending, I detest people who act as though they know the truth about any such occurrences. We humans don't know; we may have beliefs, but we decidedly do not have knowledge.

Before you jump all over my thought process on this one, let me assure you: I realize Perrotta was trying to do no such thing. I fully realize, as well, that his newest novel is a parody of sorts, making comedy out of and poking fun at such predictions. Still, the novel's premise kept me from pre-ordering the novel, despite my great appreciation of Perrotta's body of work. But then there was a contest for the audio version of The Leftovers over on the book blog nomadreader, which I entered and won.

And so, I came into possession of an audio version of Perrotta's latest novel. I was thrilled by my win, because -- despite any misgivings about its plot -- I was still excited about reading The Leftovers, simply because I admire and enjoy Perrotta's writing. I will wholeheartedly admit that perhaps an audio version was not the best way to experience this novel. There were doubtless intricacies which I missed by hearing the book rather than reading it on the page.

In the end, the characters were my favorite part of the novel. I found myself wanting to return to certain characters when Perrotta's story took me away from them for too long. That being said, I enjoyed the varying perspectives given, and the way Perrotta changed points of view frequently. Hearing about October 14 (the date of the supposed rapture in the novel) from many characters' perspectives was quite interesting. Perrotta shares thoughts from many different kinds of people, and from people whose reactions to October 14 vary considerably:

  • Grown-ups whose lives have been turned upside down, like housewife Nora, who loses her entire family to the rapture
  • Teenagers whose lives have been affected, either by loss of family members to the rapture, or to loss of family members to various cults that pop up afterwards
  • People who join said cults, including:
    • teenagers who join the Barefoot movement (think modern-day hippies)
    • followers of Holy Wayne (who leads a Healing Hug movement and impregnates one of his wives with a child who is supposed to solve everything)
    • and the creepiest of all -- the Guilty Remnant, or G.R. (a group of "watchers" for those left behind, who wear only white and smoke cigarettes "to proclaim their faith")
  • Religious folks who weren't "taken" and can't understand why

Perrotta does an excellent job of delving into the psyche of various kinds of human beings. It isn't hard to believe that if something like the rapture were to occur, people would react in much the same way: some with sadness, some with mental illness, and some with radicalism. 

But to truly give yourself over to The Leftovers, I think as a reader you must entirely suspend your disbelief. In short, you must buy into the idea of October 14. And while Perrotta's observations about the human spirit and subsequent reactions was spot-on, I simply couldn't fully immerse myself in the idea of the rapture as Perrotta told the story. In this case, I have to plead an"it's not you, it's me" argument, because I truly believe Perrotta did an excellent job with this novel. It just wasn't the novel for me. Others have praised the novel. For their thoughts, click on any of the following links:
  • Stephen King's review for the NY Times
  • Kimberly's review on the Fancy Terrible book blog
  • nomadreader's review of the novel
  • The Book Lady's Blog review
  • Ron Charles' review for the Washington Post

Tom Perrotta is the author of five other novels, including Little Children and Election, which were both made into feature films. He is currently working on an adaptation of The Leftovers for HBO. To find out more, visit his very well-done (and, of course, well-written) website.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Ready Player One Visits Both the Future and the '80s in Fantastic Style

Believe it or not, I finished a book about a futuristic video game in less than two days. I, reader of southern literature and women's fiction, with a mystery thrown in here and there, loved it. You've heard me say this before (although not that often), but this is truly one of the best books of the year. It was named one of Amazon's Best Books of the Month for August 2011. The film rights were optioned by Warner Brothers before it was published. It's been reviewed in The New York Times, USA Today, and Entertainment Weekly.

Suffice it to say Ready Player One is already a hit. But it's about a virtual-reality video game -- and it's set in the future. The main character and narrator is a geeky teenage boy gamer, the kind that never leaves his console. Not even for school. In the year 2044, when the novel is set, even getting a public education is available on the internet in the virtual reality world of OASIS. So what about this novel could have possibly appealed to me? In a word: everything.

The premise of Ernest Cline's Ready Player One is every bit as geeky as it sounds. Cline is the creator and screenplay writer of 2009's ode to Star Wars geekdom, Fanboys. He spent his youth playing Atari games and fiddling with early computers. He likes to visit comic book stores while riding around in his DeLorean. And his character in Ready Player One, Wade Watts, is his (virtual) literary twin.

Main character Watts is a gamer at his best (or worst). He has few friends, save a couple he's met in OASIS. His real life is a sad series of disappointments. He lives with his aunt in "the stacks," a tenement housing nightmare in which trailers were stacked one on top of the other in order to accommodate the influx of people to larger cities. Most of his time in real life is spent in his "hideaway," hidden from the world, submerged in OASIS.

The brainchild of two children of the '80s, OASIS originally served as a temporary escape into an internet-based virtual reality. But as the world energy crisis worsened, the infrastructures of most formerly-strong countries crumbled, and wars raged, OASIS grew both in importance and in function. When the book opens, most people spend their days in the virtual world rather than the real one. The currency of OASIS is more stable than any other form of currency around the world. Earning points in OASIS translates into money in the real world, as most everything can be bought via OASIS and delivered to your home -- food, clothing, and other goods.

People create avatars that interact in OASIS, and have the ability to keep their true identity anonymous. This was of great importance to the creators, and winning a Supreme Court battle secured this right for all of mankind. Wade takes full advantage of this right, making his avatar a thinner, better-looking version of himself, with a name -- Parzival -- that has little to do with him.



When James Halliday, one of the creators of OASIS, passes away, a contest is introduced to the world. Halliday's entire billion-dollar fortune is up for grabs to the first person to "find his egg." He begins the contest by emailing a video of himself (as avatar Anorak) to every player of OASIS on the planet. The video contains a four-line verse containing a clue about the hunt. With those four lines, an international (virtual) obsession begins:
The Hunt, as the contest came to be known, quickly wove its way into global culture. Like winning the lottery, finding Halliday's Easter egg became a popular fantasy among adults and children alike. It was a game anyone could play, and at first, there seemed to be no right or wrong way to play it. The only thing Anorak's Almanac [a collection of hundreds of Halliday's undated journal entries] seemed to indicate was that a familiarity with Halliday's various obsessions would be essential to finding the egg. This led to a global fascination with 1980s pop culture. . . . A new subculture was born, composed of the millions of people who now devoted every free moment of their lives to searching for Halliday's egg." (7-8)
Four years later, the first name appears on Halliday's website, set up to mirror a 1980s video game scoreboard: Parzival. Long after the world declared the egg "impossible to find" (8), Wade Watts, "an eighteen-year-old kid living in a trailer park on the outskirts of Oklahoma City" (9), finds the first key. In doing so, he re-fuels the world's obsession with finding the egg, and sets a series of events into motion chronicled in Ready Player One.

Ernest Cline & his DeLorean
Ready Player One has all the elements necessary for a successful novel: interesting characters with whom readers can sympathize, an action-packed and fast-moving plot, and an incredibly detailed setting (actually two, if you take into account both Cline's descriptions of earth in 2044 and the richly-described virtual OASIS world).

The constant stream of allusions to 1980s pop culture enrich the novel in ways I'm sure I don't completely understand after a single reading. Several chapters in, I had to resist the urge to start over and keep a list of all the references so that I could look them up later. While many of these are gamer-related, just as many have nothing at all to do with video games and everything to do with being a child of the '80s. Cline mixes Dungeons & Dragons with Family Ties and Rush.

Wade Watts is a memorable character who I hope to read more about in future Cline novels. As I mentioned above, Ready Player One is reportedly in the hands of Warner Brothers to develop into a film. Although recreating the rich virtual worlds of OASIS will be challenging, I look forward to seeing the adaptation in theaters.


Ernest Cline has in incredibly interesting website, which I got lost on for an hour or so before returning to finish this post. He includes everything from the inception of the movie Fanboys to a hilarious account of his childhood. Cline also writes a blog that goes back several years. The book itself also has a Tumblr blog with updates and excerpts from the novel, as well as clips and photos from some of the '80s references in the novel.

Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Lost Voices Begs the Question: Are Mermaids the New Vampires in YA Fiction?

Fantasy fiction, whether it be supernatural or otherworldly, caters to escapist fiction readers. In the YA genre in particular, it feeds teen (and older) readers' deep-seated need to travel somewhere outside the adult-driven universe in which they reside. Sarah Porter's new YA novel Lost Voices works doubly in this scenario; not only can her readers use the novel as a means of escape, but so do her characters.

Lost Voices relates the tale of those often overlooked: the beaten down, the neglected, the abused. In Porter's alternate world, girls who experience such travesties at the hands of adults -- primarily their family members or guardians -- have a way out of the chaos. They can become mermaids, free of all human responsibilities and cares. And, of course, abuses. However, nothing is at simple or easy as it seems. The cliche "too good to be true" comes to mind.

While the characters in Porter's novel escape the human world in favor of a seemingly fantasy-like life, complications arise almost from the get-go. First of all, a tribe full of adolescent female mermaids is much like a boarding school dorm or summer camp cabin -- full of jealousies, rife with conflict, and one power struggle after another. Although these girls (now mermaid creatures) have escaped their abusive human lives, they remain in many ways still very much human. Anyone who has spent any length of time around teenage girls (or boys, for that matter) know that drama is never more than a split second away, given the right atmosphere and hurt feelings, imagined or otherwise.

During my first teaching assignment out of college, I had a boy literally hurl a desk across my classroom. I believe the entire incident stemmed from another boy's comment about his girlfriend. That quickly, teenage emotions can erupt in poor decisions with (sometimes) dire consequences. Of course, we all know teens are not the only individuals who lack restraint; our prisons are full of grown-ups whose emotional reactions also got the best of them.

The mermaid tribe, led by the beautiful Catarina, rules itself based on an oral constitution of sorts. Luce, the novel's main character, quickly discovers after landing in the sea off Alaska that the mermaids all claim to follow their rules to the letter, but in actuality use them as best befits their needs or wants. She finds herself swimming among them, but feeling out of place even here. The mermaids spend their days swimming, diving, eating mussels, avoiding predatory orcas, and enjoying other (sometimes much darker) mermaid pursuits.

Luce begins to have second thoughts about her new self-made family when she is forced into situations -- and to commit acts -- she regrets. The advent of new characters keep the book interesting, despite the limitations involved in setting a book in such a secluded location. The buzz is that Lost Voices is the first novel in a trilogy the author has planned. Although I felt there were some issues (lack of plot in some places, a bit too dark in others), I will definitely read the second book in this trilogy to find out where and what main character Luce is doing.

Despite the darker themes, the writing and characters makes this an appropriate title for my middle school classroom as a book for individual students to read on their own. I would hesitate to read it aloud or teach it as a class novel simply because it is so female-centered; I doubt the thirteen- and fourteen-year-old boys in my classes would appreciate it as much as the girls would. It is also a novel I would hesitate to recommend to readers outside the YA world. If you are a teen or a YA book lover, you will most likely enjoy Lost Voices. However, it doesn't have the far-reaching power of other recent YA books such as The Hunger Games or Twilight.

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Catching Fire Blazes Katniss Back Into the Spotlight (You Have to Read These Books!)

Suzanne Collins took the book world by storm with the first novel in her Hunger Games trilogy, aptly named The Hunger Games (for my review of it, go here). She ended the first novel with somewhat of a cliffhanger; thus, the second and then the third novels in the series.

Catching Fire is the second novel in the series, and picks up directly where The Hunger Games left off. (NOTE: You should probably stop reading this post if you haven't yet read The Hunger Games. I'll try not to spoil the trilogy for you, but it's difficult not to give away at least some of the plot from the first book in discussion of the second novel within a trilogy. Suffice it to say both books are amazing -- as is Mockingjay, in spite of the bad press it received. So, go out and read them immediately! They are perfect weekend reads, beach reads, middle-of-the-week reads -- anytime reads.) Now, back to Catching Fire:

When Katniss and Peeta survive the Hunger Games in the first novel, it is a first in the history of Panem. Previously, no two tributes were ever allowed to survive together. But Katniss changed that with her actions at the end of the first novel. Historically, winning tributes have been glorified in both their Districts and in the Capitol. However, Katniss moved herself into an enemy position when she forced the Capitol's hand and saved both her own life and Peeta's. As a result, she is less glorified and more disdained. The people of Panem -- and of District 12 -- are not in on this fact. The battle is a private one between Katniss and President Snow.

So Katniss and her family move into the tribute neighborhood, a housing subdivision with nice homes and 24-hour electricity. They also have all the food they can eat. Katniss, however, is less than happy. She fears President Snow, and she has also forced herself into the spotlight. This makes hunting difficult if not impossible. Additionally, her love life is no picnic. Gale sought a job at the mines, so he is often unavailable; even if that weren't true, they live very different lives. Peeta is also at odds with Katniss, after he figured out that her affection during the Games was only a ploy to win over the audience and help them survive. So for the most part, Katniss is lonely. Lonely for her old way of life, difficult thought it may have been, and lonely for companionship.

I found myself bored with the beginning of Catching Fire. It seemed to drag on forever with little conflict to drive either the plot or the characters. However, once the Quarter Quell is announced and Katniss begins traveling as part of the lead-up to the next Games, things get more interesting. I also loved that the plot required Katniss and Peeta to interact in the second half especially. While some think Peeta is a less-than-masculine, poor substitute for Gale, I happen to love his character. What some readers infer as whiny, I see as genuine. I also think Peeta contains a quiet strength, rather than an outward physical strength.

Katniss is also unlikable in her depressive state at the beginning of the novel. Having never found myself in a life-or-death situation like the Hunger Games, however, I don't find myself in a place to judge her resulting feelings. Halfway through the novel, she became much more enjoyable a character, though. She is, truly, the "girl on fire", in more ways than one. Although much of the dialogue, setting, and even plot seems similar once the second Hunger Games in the series begins, Collins also manages to add enough newness to the story that Catching Fire is worthy of reading after the fantastic The Hunger Games. As one teacher I work with put it, "You really just want to know what happens to the characters."

The ending, in true Collins style, is every bit as exciting as Katniss's Shakespearean moment in the first novel. I'm not sure how readers of Catching Fire when it was first released stood the not-knowing. I, for one, am glad that all three books in the trilogy had already been released so that I could read them in quick succession. Coming up in the near future, my thoughts on Mockingjay.

Don't miss Book News on Fridays, which lately have featured stories about the progress being made on The Hunger Games movies. Jennifer Lawerence was cast as Katniss, news which was great to me (I loved her in Winter's Bone), but disappointing to some. The film will be released in 2012, and should be followed by movie versions of both Catching Fire and Mockingjay.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The Hunger Games Tops My 2011 Best Books List (Yes, I Realize It's Only February)

I hesitate to even write about this book, because I'm not sure I can accurately express why it worked so well. It's not a new release -- released in 2008, it is three years old. So it's old news. BUT, I have to write about it because ohmygoodnessIloveditsomuch. So much, in fact, that -- like my high school librarian told me I would -- I read it in about 24 hours. Then I read the second book in the trilogy, and the third book in the trilogy within the next week. What book am I speaking of? Why, Suzanne Collins' The Hunger Games, of course.

By the description, it sounds like the exact opposite of any book I would ever read: young adult, science fiction, futuristic, fantasy, action-packed, war-torn. Not one of those descriptions entices me to read a book. I suppose that's the reason I had so little interest in it, even though the blog world exploded with coverage of the trilogy -- and near went into panic mode waiting on the third installment to be released. Bloggers I trust and read regularly raved about it, one even decorated her Christmas tree with Hunger Games stuff (and staged a Hunger Games reenactment in her backyard), Hot Topic created a Hunger Games line, and there's an upcoming movie. Still, I resisted.

Finally, another teacher at my school read it and couldn't say enough about it. Her students read it and loved it, too. I decided I had to give it the "old college try"; I could always abandon it if I hated it. So... I didn't hate it. I loved it. It was fabulous. Life-changing, if you will. One of "those" books.

The Hunger Games trilogy begins sometime in the future. North America has been rebuilt as the country of Panem. It consists of a Capitol and 12 Districts, each with its own specific job to do. For example, District 1 creates luxury items; District 12 mines for coal; and so on. As a result of a rebellion and Civil War that occurred 75 years ago, the Capitol must remind Panem citizens that they are at the will of the government. To prove their power, the Capitol forces the Districts to engage in the Hunger Games each year. In the Hunger Games, each District draws two names -- a boy and a girl -- to act as tributes. Players are placed in an arena, and must fight to the death. The last survivor is the Game winner. Oh yes, and the entire event is broadcast, reality-television style, for all of Panem to watch.

Katniss, the book's main character, is thrown into the arena with tributes who dwarf  her in both size and intent to win. However, coming from the tough District 12 and having a few tricks up her sleeve, Katniss proves that she has enough spunk to at least be in the running inside the arena. Collins throws in a love story in addition to all the battle scenes; Katniss is swooned over by Gale back at home and Peeta in the arena.

All that tells you exactly nothing about why The Hunger Games is so good. So here is my short list:
  • Excellent writing
  • Well-developed characters
  • Interesting, unique, & creative premise
  • Great story line
  • Enough action, but so much more
  • Detailed setting -- fictional, yet based on actual United States topography
  • Strong female lead character
As I have mentioned in some of my Reading Aloud in the Classroom posts, I am currently reading The Hunger Games to my students. Some have felt the beginning was slow, especially hearing it aloud. I would agree that the beginning does nothing to foreshadow the excitement that eventually builds. Others, however, have been hooked from the get-go. I think the wild-dog stew was probably a catalyst in getting my middle-school-age boys to keep listening!

Chasing Fire and Mockingjay were also enjoyable for me, despite the backlash that followed the final book's release. More on that later!

Don't forget to return tomorrow for an interview with debut author Sara J. Henry from the blog Sara in Vermont. Her literary mystery Learning to Swim was released yesterday.

Sunday, March 14, 2010

'The Monsters of Templeton' Mixes History With Fantasy


I finished Lauren Groff's lengthy tale of a small upstate New York town, The Monsters of Templeton, just a few minutes ago. I'm quite sad to leave behind the world of Wilhemenia Upton and her secretive, cantankerous ancestors. However, since I've given the last week of my life to the book, I was also ready in some ways to be finished and leave it behind. It is an original story crafted through old letters, current events, historical documents, and imaginary narratives from people long dead.

Willie Upton has come home to Templeton, New York, to figure out what her next step in life should be. She is skinny as a rail and has short, wispy hair; she looks almost ill. The same morning of her return, a rower discovers the body of a gargantuan lake monster floating belly up in Lake Glimmerglass. As the townspeople, national media, and scientists flutter over this new-found animal, Willie tries to make sense of her own life and of what her hometown has become.

Her mother, Vivienne, is a hippie turned nurse turned born-again Christian. Willie feels she's lost her mother as Vi tools around town with the local church's pastor, a heavy cross hung around her neck. Willie's best friend Carissa is thousands of miles away in San Fransisco, ill and needing care of her own. Local boys (well, now grown men) who Willie went to high school with begin to pop up all over the place, vying for her attention. But Willie has a secret: the main reason she came home is to decide what's best for herself and the unborn baby growing inside her. In the midst of this already looming crisis, Vi surprises Willie with the news that her absent father isn't who she thought he was, and Willie sets out on a mission to find out who he actually is.

Groff set the novel in a fictional town, but it is mirrored on the town of Cooperstown, New York, the site of the Baseball Hall of Fame. Groff was born there and grew up there, prompting her to write a sort of love story to the town with this, her first novel. Although some names have changed, Groff includes many factual businesses and people.

Similarities between fictional Templeton and real-life Cooperstown:
  • The fictional Templeton is named after its founder Marmaduke Temple, as Cooperstown was named for first landowner Judge William Cooper
  • The famous Glimmerglass Opera is nearby, which Groff references in the book often
  • The Farmer's Museum is a real place in Cooperstown, attributed to Templeton in the novel
  • The National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum is in Cooperstown, which is also discussed often in the book (especially the tourists who run rampant in the town)
  • The New York State Historical Association has its library in Cooperstown, and in the book Willie Upton does much of her research there
  • One of the novel's characters is heir to a large brewing company; Cooperstown boasts its very own Brewery Ommegang, which hasn't been a long-standing family company, but rather has been brewing beer for fifteen years or so
  • In the novel local author Jacob Franklin Temple creates a legacy for Templeton and provides clues to its history, much as real-life author James Fenimore Coooper (author of The Last of the Mohicans) does for Cooperstown; Groff attributes Cooper's most famous character, Natty Bumppo, to Temple in her novel
The novel was fascinating, and I loved its characters, especially Carissa, Willie, and Vi. But it took a long time to get through. Groff went back and forth in time, from the current situation with Willie to her research involving her ancestors. Some of the historical writing was interesting, but I must admit there were also parts I simply skipped. It also seemed difficult to follow the story and/or their connection to the story at some points in the historical sections. With so many ancestor characters (I counted more than forty on a family tree Groff includes at the end of the book), it was hard to keep them all straight, even with the occasional family tree to help.

Difficulties aside, The Monsters of Templeton was a unique novel and a nice breath of fresh air after what seems like similar stories being turned out by various authors year after year. Groff has a hit with her first novel, and I can't wait to read more. She has also published a book of short stories, and it sounds like (from her website posts) she has also just finished a new novel which is in her editor's hands at the moment.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails